I really tried hard to like GTR2. It caught my eye at best buy, and I thought I'd give it a try for real.
First off, I have no idea why it has to be so huge, to me, there doesn't seem to be enough content to justify several gigabytes on my hard drive and 3 CDs to install.
The menus I don't mind particularly, they're somewhat complicated, but not too difficult. They could be much more intuitive however.
Now for the actual game, I really want to like it, but I feel so disconnected from the car I can hardly drive it. I've tried different physics mods, changed the Force Feedback, tried different tire curves, and it still feels like my car is in no way connected to the track. I can't get over the canned understeer effect, it honestly confuses me every time I get into an understeer situation.
I don't mind the sounds, they do sound very nice, but after a couple laps, I start missing the synthesized sounds from LFS, GTR2 sounds like the same recording being played over and over again. I do really like having some gearwhine though, and the pebbles hitting the bottom of the car is a nice touch.
Visuals wise, I don't see what all the hype is about. To me, neither the cars nor the tracks look all that great. I don't know what it is with the cars, but they don't seem to have any visual weight to them. They look like paper cutouts with textures driving around the track to be honest. The tracks are decent, but nothing spectacular. I'd take Aston over any of then any day. Finally about the graphics, I don't know what it is, but it totally kills my computer, I really don't think it looks good enough to justify the framerate that it has.
It seems to me like SimBin is really trying to make a realistic sim, but they can't. GTR2 doesn't need an update, the physics engine needs to be scrapped and completely recoded. I actually think Sports Car GT feels more realistic...